SmartShave vs Gillette SkinGuard: Which Razor Suits Your Shaving Routine?

SMARTSHAVE | RAZOR COMPARISON

Choosing between SmartShave and Gillette SkinGuard is not simply a question of which razor has more blades. The two systems are designed around different priorities: SkinGuard places a protective element between its two blades, while SmartShave offers three- and five-blade cartridge options with a pivoting head and lubricating strip. The right choice depends on your skin, technique, budget and how you prefer to replace blades.

At a glance: what is different?

  • Gillette SkinGuard: a two-blade cartridge with SkinGuard technology intended to minimise direct blade contact with skin that is prone to bumps and irritation.
  • SmartShave: a choice of three- or five-blade cartridge systems, with a pivoting action head, quality rubber grip and a strip containing Vitamin E and Aloe.
  • Buying model: Gillette sells SkinGuard refill packs and subscription options; SmartShave offers a £9.99 starter package and a £24.99 monthly SELECT package.

Blade design: two blades or three/five?

Gillette describes SkinGuard as a system designed to help protect bump- and breakout-prone skin by minimising contact between the blades and the skin. Its official UK product information lists a four-pack at £12.99, or about £3.25 per refill at the listed one-time price. Prices and promotions can change, so check the current Gillette SkinGuard product page before buying.

SmartShave takes a different approach. The S3 uses a three-blade head, while the S5 uses a five-blade head. A higher blade count is not automatically better for every face: comfort depends on the individual, the condition of the cartridge, the pressure used and the direction of hair growth. If you are prone to irritation, use light pressure and avoid repeatedly going over the same area.

Comfort features and handling

SkinGuard’s distinguishing feature is its protective bar between the blades, alongside lubrication before and after the blades. That design is aimed at people who want to reduce direct blade contact. It is a feature claim, not a guarantee that irritation or razor bumps will disappear.

SmartShave focuses on a pivoting action head to follow facial contours, a quality rubber grip for control and a Vitamin E and Aloe strip to help the cartridge glide. Those features may appeal if you value a familiar multi-blade cartridge shave and a handle that feels secure in the hand.

The real cost: compare like with like

A refill-pack price is not directly comparable with a complete starter or subscription package. Gillette’s SkinGuard four-pack is a refill-only purchase: you need a compatible handle. SmartShave’s £9.99 Starter Kit includes one handle and one replacement head. Its £24.99 monthly SELECT package includes one handle and four replacement heads.

Before deciding, ask how many replacement heads you actually use, whether you already own a compatible handle, and whether a recurring delivery suits you. If you already own a SkinGuard-compatible handle, buying refills may be the simplest route. If you want to try a new cartridge system with a handle included, compare the complete SmartShave starter price instead.

Which should you choose?

Choose Gillette SkinGuard if…

  • You specifically want to try its two-blade SkinGuard design.
  • You already own a compatible Gillette handle. SkinGuard refills fit SkinGuard Sensitive, ProGlide, ProShield and Fusion handles, according to Gillette/Tesco product information.
  • You prefer buying refill packs as and when needed rather than choosing a new handle package.

Consider SmartShave if…

  • You want a choice between a three-blade S3 and five-blade S5 cartridge.
  • You value a pivoting head, rubber grip and Vitamin E and Aloe lubrication strip.
  • You want a starter option that includes both a handle and a replacement head, or a SELECT package that includes four replacement heads and one handle.

For more guidance, read SmartShave’s guide to choosing a razor for sensitive skin and its tips for reducing shaving nicks and cuts.

Frequently asked questions

Is Gillette SkinGuard a five-blade razor?

No. SkinGuard uses a two-blade cartridge with a protective SkinGuard element between the blades. It is designed differently from Gillette’s five-blade Fusion range.

Does a higher blade count mean a closer or more comfortable shave?

Not necessarily. Blade count is only one factor. Hair growth direction, pressure, preparation, cartridge condition and personal skin response all matter.

Does SmartShave SELECT include four handles?

No. The £24.99 monthly SELECT package includes four replacement heads and one handle. The £9.99 Starter Kit includes one replacement head and one handle.

Try SmartShave for yourself

If you want to compare the feel of a cartridge razor without committing to a large first order, SmartShave’s £9.99 5-blade Starter Kit includes one replacement head and one handle. View the Starter Kit.

For regular shavers, the £24.99 monthly SELECT package includes four replacement heads and one handle. It is a complete package, not a refill-only price comparison. Explore monthly SELECT.

SmartShave blades feature a Vitamin E and Aloe strip, a quality rubber grip and a pivoting action head. Compare the package with your own shaving frequency and preferences before choosing.

You can also browse the SmartShave homepage for product details.